Manchester United F.C. 4–3 Manchester City F.C. (2009)

The first fixture between Manchester United and Manchester City in the 2009–10 Premier League season was played on 20 September 2009 at Old Trafford. It was the 153rd Manchester derby between the two clubs. Manchester United won the game 4–3 courtesy of a late winner from Michael Owen deep into second-half injury time. Wayne Rooney opened the scoring early on, but a mistake from Ben Foster in the United goal allowed Gareth Barry to equalise for City. Two goals each from Darren Fletcher and Craig Bellamy meant that the score was 3–3 going into four minutes of injury time, before Owen secured the win for the home side in the 96th minute. The match saw the return of striker Carlos Tevez to Old Trafford after leaving United that summer.

After the game, United manager Sir Alex Ferguson described it as "probably […] the best derby of all time".^[1] In May 2012, the match was voted as the best of the first two decades of the Premier League in the Premier League 20 Seasons Awards.^[2]

Background

The Manchester derby is a fixture contested between two football teams from the Manchester region, Manchester United and Manchester City. Before this fixture, there had been 152 meetings between the two sides, with the first fixture being held in 1881. The non-competitive fixture ended in a 3–0 victory for Newton Heath (who later became Manchester United) against West Gorton (Manchester City). The first competitive meeting was in the qualifying stages for the FA Cup in 1891, which Newton Heath also won 5–1. The most recent match between the two sides had been at Old Trafford in May 2009, when Manchester United won 2–0. In total, Manchester United had recorded 62 victories in competitive meetings with their rivals; Manchester City won 41 of the matches and there had been 49 draws.

Heading into the game, the home side Manchester United were in second place in the Premier League table after five matches, trailing Chelsea by 3 points. Manchester City were in fourth place but level on points with Manchester United, Liverpool, Tottenham Hotspur and Aston Villa, but with a game in hand on all apart from Liverpool. United had won four of their five matches, while City had won all of their first four fixtures.

Match

Teams

Manchester United had several players out of contention for the match. Paul Scholes was serving a one-match suspension, and Rio Ferdinand was considered a doubt with a calf injury, although he did eventually recover to start the match. Gabriel Obertan (calf), Rafael (shoulder), Edwin van der Sar (finger) and Owen Hargreaves (knee) were all ruled out through injury, with Hargreaves the only one with a long-term injury. Leading goalscorer Wayne Rooney, who had scored five times, started in a two-man strike partnership with Dimitar Berbatov. Park Ji-sung replaced the suspended Scholes as the only change to the starting line-up from the previous Premier League fixture against Tottenham, when he had been sent-off for two yellow cards.

Manchester City were without top-scorer Emmanuel Adebayor, who was serving a three-match ban for violent conduct in their last match against Arsenal which City had given up contesting.^[3] He was replaced by Carlos Tevez, who was an injury doubt but was fit enough to start on his return to his former club in the only change for City. Robinho, Vincent Kompany and Roque Santa Cruz all missed out through injury.

Summary

The derby turned out to be a classic, with City's Craig Bellamy and United's Darren Fletcher playing main roles. Wayne Rooney gave United first blood after just a bit more than one minute, but Gareth Barry was able to equalise after a quarter of an hour. Midfielder Fletcher then entered the frame, scoring on 49 minutes. A quick equaliser from Bellamy made sure the scores were levelled after 52 minutes. With ten minutes remaining, Fletcher made it 3–2. The game was far from won for United, however, since Bellamy scored a dramatic equaliser on 90 minutes. However, lots of time was added on, and in the sixth additional minute, substitute Michael Owen struck 4–3 from close range to cap a remarkable derby.

Referee Martin Atkinson was criticised by Manchester City's manager Mark Hughes for bad time-keeping. The fourth official had signalled four minutes of additional time, but Michael Owen scored a 96th-minute goal.^[4] Atkinson was defended by former referee Graham Poll, himself considered one of England's greatest officials,^[5] who pointed out that during injury time itself there had been a goal celebration, a substitution and a delay caused by a fan on the pitch.^[6]

Details

Manchester United v Manchester City

20 September 2009 13:30

Manchester United	4–3	Manchester City
Rooney  2' Fletcher  49', 80' Owen  90+6'	Report	Barry  16' Bellamy  52', 90'

Old Trafford, Manchester Attendance: 75,066 Referee: Martin Atkinson (West Yorkshire)

Manchester United

Manchester City

GK 12 Ben Foster RB 22 John O'Shea CB 5 Rio Ferdinand CB 15 Nemanja Vidić  43' LB 3 Patrice Evra RM 13 Park Ji-sung  62' CM 8 Anderson  36'  90+3' CM 24 Darren Fletcher LM 11 Ryan Giggs CF 10 Wayne Rooney CF 9 Dimitar Berbatov  78' Substitutes: GK 29 Tomasz Kuszczak DF 2 Gary Neville DF 23 Jonny Evans MF 16 Michael Carrick  90+3' MF 17 Nani MF 25 Antonio Valencia  62' FW 7 Michael Owen  78' Manager: Sir Alex Ferguson

GK 1 Shay Given RB 2 Micah Richards CB 19 Joleon Lescott CB 28 Kolo Touré LB 3 Wayne Bridge CM 18 Gareth Barry CM 34 Nigel de Jong  83' RW 8 Shaun Wright-Phillips AM 7 Stephen Ireland LW 39 Craig Bellamy  55' CF 32 Carlos Tevez  27' Substitutes: GK 12 Stuart Taylor DF 5 Pablo Zabaleta DF 15 Javier Garrido DF 16 Sylvinho MF 17 Martin Petrov  83' MF 40 Vladimír Weiss FW 50 David Ball Manager: Mark Hughes

Statistics

References

External links

• Match Stats - Manchester United v Manchester City at guardian.co.uk