Energy hierarchy

The Energy Hierarchy with the most favoured options at the top

Part of a series about
Sustainable energy
Energy conservation
Cogeneration Efficient energy use Green building Heat pump Low-carbon power Microgeneration Passive solar building design
Renewable energy
Anaerobic digestion Geothermal Hydroelectricity Solar Tidal Wind
Sustainable transport
Carbon-neutral fuel Electric vehicle Fossil fuel phase-out Green vehicle Plug-in hybrid
Sustainable development portal Renewable energy portal Environment portal

The Energy Hierarchy is a classification of energy options, prioritised to assist progress towards a more sustainable energy system. It is a similar approach to the waste hierarchy for minimising resource depletion, and adopts a parallel sequence.

The highest priorities cover the prevention of unnecessary energy usage both through eliminating waste and improving energy efficiency. The sustainable production of energy resources is the next priority. Depletive and waste-producing energy generation options are the lowest priority.

For an energy system to be sustainable: the resources applied to producing the energy must be capable of lasting indefinitely; energy conversion should produce no harmful by-products, including net emissions, nor wastes which cannot be fully recycled; and it must be capable of meeting reasonable energy demands.

Energy saving

The top priority under the Energy Hierarchy is energy conservation or the prevention of unnecessary use of energy. This category includes eliminating waste by turning off unneeded lights and appliances and by avoiding unnecessary journeys. Heat loss from buildings is a major source of energy wastage,^[1] so improvements to building insulation and air-tightness can make a significant contribution to energy conservation.^[2]

Many countries have agencies to encourage energy saving.^[3][4]

Energy efficiency

The second priority under the energy hierarchy is to ensure that energy that is used is produced and consumed efficiently. Energy efficiency has two main aspects.

Conversion efficiency of energy consumption

Energy efficiency is the ratio of the productive output of a device to the energy it consumes.^[5]

Energy efficiency was a lower priority when energy was cheap and awareness of its environmental impact was low. In 1975 the average fuel economy of a car in the US was under 15 miles per gallon^[6] Incandescent light bulbs, which were the most common type until the late 20th century, waste 90% of their energy as heat, with only 10% converted to useful light.^[7]

More recently, energy efficiency has become a priority.^[8] The last reported average fuel efficiency of US cars had almost doubled from the 1975 level;^[6] LED lighting is now being promoted which are between five and ten times more efficient than incandescents.^[9] Many household appliances are now required to display labels to show their energy efficiency.

Conversion efficiency of energy production

Losses are incurred when energy is harvested from the natural resource from which it is derived, such as fossil fuels, radioactive materials, solar radiation or other sources. Most electricity production is in thermal power stations, where much of the source energy is lost as heat. The average efficiency of world electricity production in 2009 was c.37%.^[10]

A priority in the Energy Hierarchy is to improve the efficiency of energy conversion, whether in traditional power stations^[11] or by improving the performance ratio of Photovoltaic power stations^[12] and other energy sources.

Overall efficiency and sustainability can also be improved by capacity- or fuel-switching from less efficient, less sustainable resources to better ones; but this is mainly covered under the fourth level of the hierarchy.

Sustainable energy production

Renewable energy describes naturally occurring, theoretically inexhaustible sources of energy.^[13] These sources are treated as being inexhaustible, or naturally replenished, and fall into two classes.

Elemental renewables

The first class of renewables derive from climatic or elemental sources,^[14] such as sunlight, wind, waves, tides or rainfall (hydro power). Geothermal energy from the heat of the earth's core also falls in this category.

These are treated as being inexhaustible because most derive ultimately from energy emanating from the sun, which has an estimated life of 6.5 billion years.^[15]

Bio-energy

The other main class of renewables, bioenergy,^[16] derives from biomass, where the relatively short growing cycle means that usage is replenished by new growth. Bioenergy is usually converted by combustion, and therefore gives rise to carbon emissions. It is treated as carbon neutral overall, because an equivalent amount of carbon dioxide will have been extracted from the atmosphere during the growing cycle.^[17]

Bioenergy sources can be solid, such as wood and energy crops; liquid, such as biofuels; or gaseous, such as biomethane from anaerobic digestion.^[18]

Low impact energy production

The next priority in the hierarchy covers energy sources that are not entirely sustainable, but have a low environmental impact. These include the use of fossil fuels with carbon capture and storage.^[19]

Nuclear energy is sometimes treated as a low impact source, because it has low carbon emissions.

High impact energy production

The lowest priority under the energy hierarchy is energy production using unsustainables sources, such as unabated fossil fuels. Some also place nuclear energy in this category, rather than the one above, because of the required management/storage of highly hazardous radioactive waste over extremely long (hundreds of thousands of years or more) timeframes ^[20] and depletion of uranium resources.^[21]

There is a consensus that the share of such energy sources must decline.^[22]

Within this tier, there are possibilities for limiting adverse impacts by switching from the most damaging fuel sources, such as coal, to less emittive sources, such as gas.^[23]

Many suggest that when such high impact energy usage has been minimised, the effects of any unavoidable residual usage should be counterbalanced by emissions offsetting.^[24]

Origins of the energy hierarchy

The Energy Hierarchy was first proposed in 2005 by Philip Wolfe,^[25] when he was Director General of the Renewable Energy Association. This first version had three levels; energy efficiency, renewables and traditional energy production. It was endorsed and adopted in 2006 by a consortium of institutions, associations and other bodies in the Sustainable Energy Manifesto.^[26] Subsequently the concept has been adopted and refined by others in the energy industry^[27] and in government.^[28][29]

See also

• Energy law
• Energy policy
• List of books about energy issues
• Maslow's hierarchy of needs
• Soft energy path
• Waste hierarchy

References