Carbon dioxide cleaning

Engineers in a cleanroom, using CO₂ snow to clean the secondary reflector of the James Webb Space Telescope

Carbon dioxide cleaning (CO₂ cleaning) comprises a family of methods for parts cleaning and sterilization, using carbon dioxide in its various phases.^[1] It is often preferred for use on delicate surfaces.^{[2][3][4]:275} CO₂ cleaning has found application in the aerospace, automotive, electronics, medical, and other industries.^[5][6] Carbon dioxide snow cleaning has been used to remove particles and organic residues from metals, polymers, ceramics, glasses, hard drives, optics, and other surfaces.^[4]:270

Applications

CO₂ cleaning has found application in many industries and technical areas, including aerospace, automotive, electronics, medical, manufacturing, basic and applied research, and optics.^[5][6] The different carbon dioxide cleaning methods can remove gross contamination, paint, overlayers, grease, fingerprints, particles down to nanometers in size, hydrocarbon and organic residues, and radioactive residues. Materials cleaned include metals, polymers, ceramics, glasses, wafers, hard drives, and optics.^[4]:270 The key limitation is that the contamination must be on the surface, not buried within the material. Porous materials are not good candidates for pellets or snow, but can be cleaned using liquid or supercritical CO₂.

Methods

Carbon dioxide cleaning (CO₂ cleaning) refers to several different methods for parts cleaning, and each CO₂ phase plays a role.^[7] The basic methods include solid dry ice pellets, liquid CO₂, CO₂ snow (a hybrid method), and supercritical CO₂. The different forms of CO₂ cleaning can clean many types of objects, from large generators to small delicate parts.

Pellets

In pellet cleaning ("dry-ice blasting"), relatively large pellets of solid CO₂ are fired at the surface to be cleaned. These pellets impinge on the surface, mechanically dislodging contaminant particles. Pellet cleaning is only appropriate for surfaces which can withstand significant impacts.^[1][4]:276

Snow cleaning

In CO₂ snow cleaning, compressed liquid or gaseous carbon dioxide is expelled from a nozzle, condensing into a mixture of solid particles and gas, which impact the surface to be cleaned.^[1][4]:276 Jet velocities are frequently supersonic.^[8] Snow cleaning works by a combination of momentum transfer (mechanically dislodging contaminant particles) and solvent action.^[1][4]:273 The CO₂ sublimates on contact, increasing in volume up to 800 times, thereby generating pressure to sweep particles away.^[8] The CO₂ also dissolves hydrocarbon contaminants, and embrittles residues such as fingerprints, making them easier to blow away.^[2][9]

Snow cleaning has found application in the aeronautical, automotive, medical, optical, semiconductor, and space industries. It can provide a gentle cleaning, appropriate for delicate surfaces.^{[2][4]:270[9]} The effectiveness of carbon dioxide snow cleaning has been demonstrated via light microscopy, particle counting, scanning electron microscopy, miroprobing, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, atomic-force microscopy,^[10][11] and mass spectroscopy.^[4]:279

Supercritical fluid

At temperatures and pressures above its critical point, CO₂ can be maintained as a supercritical fluid, exhibiting extremely low viscosity and high solvency. To apply this method, parts to be cleaned are enclosed in a pressure vessel that is then filled with supercritical CO₂. This method is appropriate for small and delicate parts, and is not ideal for particulate removal.^[1] Many applications exist for supercritical carbon dioxide besides cleaning, including targeted chemical supercritical fluid extraction and materials processing. One cleaning example has been in microelectronics.^[12]

Liquid CO₂ washing

Liquid CO₂ washing, like supercritical fluid CO₂ washing, relies on the high solvent power of CO₂,^[4]:275 but at lower temperatures and pressures, the latter making it simpler to implement. Because liquid CO₂ does not have the solvent power of supercritical fluid, agitation and surfactants may be added to improve the effectiveness of the method.^[1] Liquid CO₂ has been used in dry cleaning and machined parts degreasing.

History

Carbon dioxide cleaning was contemplated in the 1930s, and the "pellet" approach was developed in the 1970s by E.E. Rice, C.H. Franklin, and C.C. Wong.^[4]:276

The introduction of CO₂ snow cleaning, with its ability to remove sub-micron-scale particles, is credited to Stuart Hoenig of the University of Arizona, who first published on the topic in 1985-1986.^[4]:277[13] Hoenig traveled the US to demonstrate the technology, eventually attracting the interest of The BOC Group, which developed Venturi nozzles for the process, and Hughes Aircraft, which developed straight nozzles.^[14] CO₂ snow cleaning was further developed by the Fraunhofer Institute for Manufacturing Engineering and Automation IPA, for the purpose of removing paint from aircraft fuselages.^[9]

Nozzle design is the most significant factor in carbon dioxide snow cleaning performance, affecting the size and velocity of the dry ice particles.^{[4]:277–278} Variations in nozzle design have been developed by W.H. Whitlock, L.L. Layden, Applied Surface Technologies, and Sierra Systems Group.^[4]:277

Issues

Safety

CO₂ cleaning may present certain safety risks. If the process is used to remove hazardous materials, precautions must be taken to avoid exposure to these materials in the vent stream. Because the CO₂ stream is cryogenic, it may cause injury with direct skin contact. In addition, care must be taken to prevent the concentration of carbon dioxide in the work area from exceeding safe levels.^[4]:272[15]

Contamination

Some commercial grades of carbon dioxide may contain traces of heavy hydrocarbons, which can be left behind on the surface being cleaned. Abrasive particles originating in the cleaning equipment itself may need to be filtered out as well. The low temperature of the carbon dioxide stream can also cause moisture condensation on the part, which may be mitigated with hot plates, heat guns, heat lamps, or dry boxes.^{[4]:292–294}

Costs

Equipment costs for a carbon dioxide snow cleaning system can range from US$1500 for a basic system to $50,000 for a high-end automated unit.^[4]:292 Material costs are comparatively low, although ultra-pure CO₂ must often be used to avoid the introduction of new contaminants.

Static charge

Ionization caused by the flowing gas can result in static charge buildup on non-conductive parts. This can be mitigated by grounding or positive ionization sources.^[4]:294

References