All Happy Families Are Alike

"All Happy Families Are Alike" is the 22nd episode and finale of the first season of the FOX series Gotham. The episode was written by series developer Bruno Heller and directed by Danny Cannon. It was first broadcast in May 4, 2015 in FOX. In this episode, the mob war between Carmine Falcone (John Doman) and Salvatore Maroni (David Zayas) is coming to a brutal end while Oswald Cobblepot and Fish Mooney (Jada Pinkett Smith) face off in their final confrontation, putting James Gordon (Benjamin McKenzie) in the middle of both conflicts. Meanwhile, Bruce Wayne (David Mazouz) sets out to find evidence that his father had a secret life before his death.

The episode marked the final appearance by Pinkett Smith in the series, as her character is killed off. Pinkett Smith previously announced that she would leave Gotham once the first season is over.^[1] It also features the final appearance of Doman and Zayas as mob bosses Falcone and Maroni. This marked the end of the mob-war season arc.

The episode received mixed reviews.

Plot

A group of street children, among them Selina, witness the arrival of Fish Mooney and the escapees from Dollmaker's Island. Mooney approaches Selina and states that it will be a "new day". Selina and the children soon join Mooney's gang.

Two weeks later, Bruce becomes convinced his father led a double life and with help from Alfred, he looks throughout his father's study room. Carmine Falcone is shot during an ambush in the port by Maroni's men and taken to the hospital. At the GCPD, Barbara decides to take trauma counselling from Dr. Leslie Thompkins after the death of her parents at the hands of The Ogre.

Cobblepot and Butch Gilzean arrive at the hospital, intending to kill Falcone. Cobblepot reveals planning the mob war since before planning with Falcone the conspiration. Gordon stops them and handcuffs Cobblepot and Butch to a pipe and frees Falcone. Falcone will need two days in a hideout to find a way to find out how to stop the war and Gordon agrees to help him. Cobblepot, realizing Maroni's men are coming and will kill him for his betrayal, pleads Gordon to free him, citing the favor Gordon owns him. Commissioner Loeb arrives with Maroni's hitmen and orders them to kill Gordon and Falcone. A shootout between Gordon and the hitmen ensues with Gordon killing the hitmen. With help from Bullock, Gordon, Falcone, Cobblepot and Gilzean escape in an ambulance.

They get to Falcone's safe house but are taken hostage by Mooney's gang. Mooney is even more furious after noticing Butch's brainwashing treatment received by Victor Zsasz and Cobblepot. Mooney makes a trade with Maroni: in exchange for Falcone's head, Maroni will return Mooney's territories. Mooney also plans on killing Cobblepot for brainwashing Butch but spares Bullock's life. However, during the meeting with Maroni, Maroni makes sexist comments on Mooney, which causes her to shoot him in the head. Maroni's and Mooney's gangs then emerge in a fight, which gives enough time to Falcone, Gordon, and Bullock to escape to a cargo container. Falcone decides he's "done" with business and plans on retiring. Selina's gang recaptures them and bring them back to Mooney. Cobblepot appears with a machine gun and kills some gang members. He then pursues Mooney to the rooftop of the warehouse while Falcone, Gordon and Bullock escape. Meanwhile, during the therapy, Barbara reveals that she murdered her parents, enraged that they never loved her. She then suffers a psychotic breakdown and proceeds to attempt to kill Leslie. Leslie manages to neutralize Barbara in self-defense just as Gordon, Falcone, and Bullock arrive.

In the rooftop of the warehouse, Mooney and Cobblepot engage in a violent fight. Butch arrives with a gun, but as he was brainwashed by Cobblepot and for his loyalty to Mooney, he doesn't know who to shoot. Unknowingly, he shoots both of them. Mooney forgives Butch for shooting her but Cobblepot knocks Butch. He then pushes Mooney to the edge of the rooftop, which makes her to fall in the water, seemingly killing her. A shocked Butch watches in horror as Cobblepot raises to the edge of the rooftop and shouting: "I am the king of Gotham!".

In the GCPD, in the file room, Kristen Kringle reveals to Nygma something she found in the note from "Dougherty": the first letter of each line spells out N-Y-G-M-A, his surname. Nygma denies any knowledge of the letter. When Kringle leaves, he suffers a mental breakdown and talking to an alternate personality that has manifested itself in his mind. Before leaving Gotham, Falcone gives Gordon a knife Falcone's father gave him, stating: "the knife is a good friend when you have no others". In the final scene, Bruce and Alfred find nothing in the study. After Alfred states "none so blind", referring to Marcus Aurelius, recalling Lucius Fox calling his father "stoic". He finds a book with a device. He turns it on and makes the fireplace recede. The season ends with Bruce and Alfred finding stairs behind the fireplace, leading to a cave.

Reception

Ratings

The episode was watched by 4.93 million viewers.^[2] This was an increase in viewership from the previous episode, which was watched by 4.58 million viewers.^[3] This made Gotham the most watched program of the day in FOX, beating The Following.

Critical reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
Source	Rating
Rotten Tomatoes (Tomatometer)	59%[4]
Rotten Tomatoes (Average Score)	7.3[4]
IGN	6.3[5]
The A.V Club	B[6]
GamesRadar	[7]
Paste Magazine	8.5[8]
TV Fanatic	[9]
New York Magazine	[10]

"All Happy Families Are Alike" received mixed reviews from critics but acclaim from fans. The episode received a "rotten" rating of 59% with an average score of 7.3 out of 10 on the review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, with the site's consensus stating: "'All Happy Families are Alike' brings season one of Gotham to a somewhat confusing conclusion, but some exciting twists hint at a promising, and hopefully more consistent, season two."^[4]

Matt Fowler of IGN gave the episode a "okay" 6.3 out of 10 and wrote in his verdict: "Gotham's Season 1 finale had some cool parts involving a freshly insane Barbara and an unexpected mob death, but the rest of it was so dang sloppy (Fish's attire, Selina joining Fish, Falcone quitting, Butch's brainwashing all of a sudden returning after being ignored for months, etc)."^[5]

Darren Orf of EW stated: "Gotham's first season ends much as it lived—with confusion, poorly plotted scenes and by turning a blind eye to everything that makes Batman great. To say 'All Happy Families Are Alike' is a letdown would be to expect too much from this finale to begin with. But after this week's episode finally cuts to black and the credits roll, it’s hard not to feel like the entire first year was a missed opportunity."^[11]

The A.V. Club's Kyle Fowle gave the episode a "B" grade and wrote, "The first season of Gotham has been a mess of incomplete or simply terrible ideas, but much of the finale proves that the show does have something to offer when it remains focused. The mob power struggle was dragged out over too many episodes, but the finale boasts a narrative concision that’s promising for the show moving forward. There's hope that after an auspicious start, Gotham has found a bit of footing in the last half of this season. Then again, maybe Penguin is right: 'Hope? It’s for losers.'"^[6]

References